35 Comments
User's avatar
Anne Trudell's avatar

Isn't the US defense industry years behind on delivering stuff? (all those Patriot missles expended in Iran that will take YEARS to replace come to mind) Isn't it always getting more expensive? That's not the kind of vendor I'd trust for vital defense stuff!

Steven M.'s avatar

Yes, it is. And, like all programs that are fully or mostly funded by governments in most countries, wherever there is an avalanche of money being spent by almost any government, waste and fraud are certain to follow. We have quite a record of misspent government money in Canada, but since defence spending in the US is about $1 trillion per year, you and I can only imagine the scale of the misspending by the Pentagon. Also, there are frequent delays in almost any project that government funds.

Marie Moneysmith's avatar

Watching this administration be rejected and humiliated by so many former allies is the best thing that's happened lately. It's a sad commentary on where we are as a country. But it won't always be this way (fingers crossed). There are more good people here than awful ones and someday we'll put this whole ugly episode behind us.

Mary Lummis's avatar

“Mark Carney’s response to the PJBD pause was one cold sentence: he wouldn’t “overplay the importance” of it. Cooperation with the US continues, he said — and Canada will diversify with other partners.

That is not the voice of a country that got dumped. That’s the voice of a country reading a desperate text from an ex and putting the phone face down.”

Love this quote!

Susan Wells's avatar

As a Texan, I envy and applaud Canada. One line in the essay gave me a giggle when it mentioned the "Department of War" because it isn't a thing. It is still officially the Department of Defense just as DJT's "Gulf of America" is still the Gulf of Mexico. Oh sure, DJT and Hegseth can call them whatever they want, they can even call them a "ham sandwich", but no matter how much mustard you smear on it, it's still a ham sandwich.

Sandra's avatar

Brilliant✨🇨🇦💫

Richard Van Atta's avatar

Geeeze—an arrogant bombastic bullshitter gets outmaneuvered by a country that actually cares about its security and not sucking up to a blackmailing, unreliable supplier. Years ago I was involved in joint US-Canadian defense industrial base cooperation. WE WERE PARTNERS! Now this Maladministration has screwed up what was impossible to screw up. The posturing and posing of Trumphuk and Hogsbreath backfired.

Good for Canada!

Terry R's avatar

Excellent overview of the situation and politics/mechanics. Thank you

Kathleen Saunders's avatar

A very well-wriiten article, Dean. I didnt know any of this background, other than the U.S. government has treated a wonderful ally horribly. Ths is a very sad story for us. We now need Canada more than ever. Thanks, Donald, for messing up again.

Stephen ONeill's avatar

Elbows Up, Canada. The US MIC has grown too large. Time to cut it down to size...and Trump, too.

Laura D 💪🇨🇦's avatar

Perfect analogy 👉 “This is an ex who ghosted you, trashed you to everyone at the party, threatened to annex your house, and slapped tariffs on your stuff — then mailed you a classified letter explaining how the next chapter of your relationship is going to go.”

Steven M.'s avatar

I have a couple of comments in relation to your narrative about the cancellation of the Avro Arrow program (CF-105). It should be noted from the outset that I knew one of Avro-Arrow's employees, who was one of the many people whom the company was forced to lay off on February 20, 1959.

There were a number of problems with the CF-105 development. For one thing, it had an estimated combat radius or flight range of 300 miles (about 488 kms. Although that aircraft was designed for very high speeds, it lacked the range that fighter jets would require in Canada, whose air space is quite vast

The person I knew who worked at Avro-Arrow went to work for A.V. Roe Canada Limited not long out of high school (he graduated in 1955) as an aircraft mechanic. That company was paying wages that were quite high for their time - about $5.00 per hour - and few, if any, private sector companies could close to matching. (The average wage for all employees didn't hit $5,000 per year until about 1962.)

There were significant cost overruns in the CF-105 project, which is not surprising given that federal government money was involved. (There are significant cost overruns in federal government projects even to this day.) Also, the person whom I knew said once that there was a lot of downtime, which employees of A.V. Roe spent, to a great, reading comic books.

Something else not well known about this project is that the CF-105 had no buyers in the US, Britain, or France,

This same friend of mine became bored with the work that he was doing and applied for a job with a major life insurance company (one that has since been taken over by one of the major companies that's still a leader in its field.) He didn't get a call from that company until after the CF-105 project was shut down by the Diefenbaker government. It offered him a job as a junior computer programmer at $65 per week, a significant drop from what he had been earning at A.V. Roe Canada, where he had been pulling in more than $5.00 per hour, or over $200 per week. But, $65 dollars per week was a fairly common starting salary in 1959.

After more than 31 years of being employed by this major life insurance firm, he retired. He died in 2011. But, he was promoted over time by that company to become Vice President of EDP (Electronic Data Processing), which position he held for a number of years before he retired. For him and for many other employees of A.V. Roe Canada who were laid off in February 1959, the cancellation of the CF-105 program, or Avro-Arrow, turned out to be a blessing in disguise. The point of my detailed response was / is to fill in some details that often get left out of the rather biased and not well-informed criticism of the CF-105's cancellation by the Diefenbaker government.

Also not part of most of the narrative about the CF-105 / Avro-Arrow program is that the Liberal government of Louis St-Laurent, if it had been re-elected in June 1957 with a majority of the House of Commons seats (and the Liberal Party might have been re-elected to a majority government, if Louis St-Laurent, then 75, had retired at the beginning of 1957, as his most senior Cabinet minister C.D. Howe had recommended to him, along with his own retirement, and Lester Pearson had been chosen as its leader then, instead of in January 1958), was seriously considering the cancellation of that same program, too. One of its major concerns was the rampant cost overruns of the Avro-Arrow CF-105 program, which I said earlier is a hallmark of almost all programs that are fully funded by our federal government. Also, as I have said, wherever there is an avalanche of federal government money being spent on some program or another, waste and fraud are certain to follow. AND, I used to work for the Canada Revenue Agency (previously known as the Department of National Revenue), so I know full well of what I say.

Joanne Miller's avatar

Love our fore planning Great to give Frump the middle finger.👏🏼

Joseph F Wightman's avatar

HOW WE GOT TRUMP 2.0

CORPORATE COMMUNIST BUSINESS PLAN (It’s not a conspiracy; it is a business plan.)

Russia and China are red states.

Why would anyone feel there is a need for a metaphor about Corporate Communism? The short answer: political marketing.

The fascist Trump MAGA right is using socialist as a bludgeon to attack every bipartisan social progress program of the twentieth century (yes, I mean FDR, Eisenhower, Reagan, Nixon, JFK, LBJ, Obama, Biden, et al). Ninety nine percent of the US population, because of Corporate Communist Fox, has no idea what socialism is other than being the spawn of Satan. It is time to put these liars on their back foot by being forced to defend the lack of free and fair media.

“Corporate Communism” is when oblivious and frequently incompetent corporations own the means of communication which is a very long-winded way of saying propaganda. Propaganda rules the world. All I have to do is to mention any religion and all of you have a visceral reaction no matter what your denomination. Propaganda pervades every aspect of our lives. Show me two religions and I will show you a war, frequently within the same dogma denomination. On the corporate side propaganda is done through the ownership of major corporations that provide us with supposed news. This is a failure on many levels, not only in the slanting and editorializing of the news, but more importantly, the editorial decision of what to cover or what to ignore. Right now, the corporate communist news industry covers only things that support oligarchy. To quote Senator Sanders. “In America today, we have more media concentration than we have ever had. Just six international media corporations control 90% of what American people see here and read. They own the traditional media, newspapers, radio and TV networks and movie studios as well as much of the Internet…three huge Wall Street firms Vanguard, BlackRock and State Street are the major stockholders in 95% of the S&P 500 corporations. And in other words, they have significant influence over many hundreds of companies that employ millions of American workers. And in fact, the entire economy.” This is accomplished by the production of false information via the privatization of Big Brother (Palantir, Google, X aka Gulf of Twitter, Facebook, Amazon, Instagram, etc.). It is the worst of both utopian fantasies, e.g. altruism is a natural human trait and that the invisible hand is more than a metaphor.

In NYC, a self-described socialist Zohran Mamdani resoundingly won in the race for Mayor. During the campaign an ad by political entertainer and Republican mayoral candidate Curtis Sliwa who had less leadership experience than Mamdani attacked the leadership and ethics of Cuomo and Adams while yelling “Socialist” about Mamdani. The conservavictim whiny little bitch corporate communist media is spreading the fear lies that NYC businesses will leave NYC for Texas etc. since they have the same educated employee hiring pool as NYC.

A Note on Conspiracy Theory: A popular belief among life’s victims (conservavictims and libtards) is that they are not to blame for their lack of success because “those forces” such as space aliens, frequently with lasers, immigrants and beings with mystic power, e.g. The Illuminati are aligned against them, and “those people” (usually ethnic and or religious groups) all sticking together to subvert their pure patriotic programs.

Corporate Communism is anti-capitalism (Adam Smith and Ayn Rand). It is anti-communist, (Marx and Stalin). It is anti-competitive in its core. It hates the free market. Loves big government which it owns. Classic Capitalism and Classic Communism are utopian dreams based on the perfectibility of humans. The stunning materialist success of classic Capitalism in remaking the world is that it most closely follows the depraved human (that is us) indifference to consequences. The stunning failure of Russian/Chinese, Stalinist Communism is that it assumed that imperfect dogma dog bureaucrats could manage something other than being dogma dog bureaucrats: Red Guard political officers in every organization.

The Corporate Communist Business Plan Privatizing Big Brother:

• Elect a useful idiot wholly controlled by those with extortion and blackmail skills and evidence. (Trump-Epstein anyone?).

• Neuter Citizen Voting (Citizens United: corporations are people) an armed guard at polling places to demand “your papers please” to prevent non-proven voter fraud.

• Neuter The Free Press Aka the Fourth Estate and free speech while maintaining the fantasy of freedom (Free Speech Absolutist) through bogus litigation, denial of access, and ownership of the means of communication. Consolidation of media.

• A note on Free Speech Absolutism: Free speech is absolutely protected from the government. That’s it, full stop. It does not mean everybody has the right to have their words and speech published, streamed, broadcast, sculpted, painted or sent via smoke signals “Freedom of the press is guaranteed only to those who own one". A. J. Liebling”..

• Ongoing degradation and subjugation of women via BFFI (BruteForceFuckingIgnorance) and tax-free religion. E.g. Clinton, Harris, Warren, Klobuchar, Ferraro. Compare and contrast with Nixon, Trump, Bush, et al. G$D created man and woman in their own image but no one has ever seen him/her/them yet almost always has a beard. Hell, even Satan has a beard. Why do popular (actually, all) religions get to have their superstitions subsidized by the government as tax free business? Please don’t say they do good work like the Godfather passing out turkeys on Thanksgiving right before DeNiro shoots him. I think it was abortion and Germaine Greer, and Susan Brownmiller via Playboy, (I only read the articles and interviews e.g. Ayn Rand) that I found the additional cracks in my dogma. What, exactly are men so terrified of? Why are G$D’s women frequently covered from head to toe due to the male BFFI (Brute Force and Fucking Ignorance) run societies and religions. Could it be self-awareness by men that they cannot control their most base instincts or perhaps confusing musculature bravado with self-esteem? Currently this is Trumpism writ large. Could not men have come up with a civilization that did not need to stand on the throats of 50% of the world’s population to develop both the A bomb and the Cybertruck? It seems that men have not completely exempted themselves from abusive dogma like mandatory facial hair and celibacy as to women. Good thing we are the top of the food chain.

• Neuter Government Oversight of the economy (Chevron Doctrine), DOGE. and e.g. elimination of the CFPB Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

• Cut Education Funding (eliminate critical thinking and awareness of facts about tiny hands).

• The anti-capitalist mentality: Elimination of Classic Capitalism Free Market Competition via Anti-Customer Service (“Your call is very important to us and the robot will be right with you”), tax funded bailouts. Consolidation of industries to eliminate effective competition.

• Denying that personal information: medical, financial e.g. credit scores, accident, dating, social, religious is actually individual private property like homes, stamp collections, cars, shoes, underwear. This theft of private property is frequently self-inflicted via free shipping and rewards by uploading your life to Big Brother social media or most likely in terms of agreement you signed and never read. Let’s not forget DOGE: since there is no controls or oversight, possibly most Musk minions stolen data will wind up as an Xfile without rewards or free shipping.

o This from Consumer Reports: “Imagine being charged more for an airline ticket to a family member’s funeral just because you searched for their obituary online. ..surveillance pricing’ happens because corporations are allowed to secretly use your personal information against you – charging different prices based on how much they think you’re willing to pay, or how badly you need their product or service.”

o

• Indentured Servitude (Employee responsible for their pension and medical insurance).

• Permanent Financial Crisis and business bailouts.

• Tax Free Theocracy. Christo Fascism

• Full Unemployment via “The Singularity aka Homo AI”

• Return of a King (Donnie The Dumb)

Joewightman.substack.com “One Eyed King”

Richard Van Atta's avatar

Phew! This is a lot…. And pretty much on point. While your lingo is a bit strident (as is mine sometimes) your assessment is essentially correct.

We are being afflicted with Corporatism combined with a strain of pseudo religious racist misogynistic “philosophy” that is used to justify the control by the CABAL of the Oligarchs. Their control of the media is key. They control the narrative and feed the public pablum.

For most it’s biz as usual… just activist in China and Russia…. Just feed the machine and shut the fuck up.

I could say much more but let’s just say this …

The system is about to implode.

Dan House's avatar

Dean, a beautiful metaphor for * arrogance *.

Barbara Upshaw's avatar

After reading your post, Dean, all I could think was what class, honor and integrity Canada has displayed throughout this mess. Somehow, those at the top have forgotten the true meaning of being a neighbor, partner and ally. As a child, I learned the words to your anthem and love the line, “Oh Canada we stand on guard for thee” and always thought how great it was to have such great neighbors who were standing on guard for us as we were for you. I pray that someday soon we will find our way back to that place. God bless you all. 🇺🇸🇨🇦

Joe Franklin's avatar

Most definitely an empire in decline and a gangster regime going down the rabbit hole.

Dr. Patricia Morton's avatar

What the orange monster clearly doesn’t understand is that we Canadians will always stand up to bullies, and that we WILL remain strong and free! 🇨🇦 🇨🇦 💕